Parker gives the 2004 Vintage 94 points. Here is his review...

Atypically, the 2004 Chateauneuf du Pape Pierres Dorees may
be even better than the 2003, offering a deep ruby/plum color
followed by sweet kirsch liqueur, resin, licorice, smoke, aged
beef, and black currant notes.

-Robert Parker, Wine Advocate #163 (Feb 2006)